Category Archives: sex discrimination

What Is The Shifting Burden of Proof In Sex Discrimination Claims?

I recently represented a case of sexual harassment in the employment tribunal.  Due to the huge amount of conflicting evidence that was heard, the tribunal panel had to consider the shifting burden of proof.

In many sex discrimination there is no clear cut evidence and there will be different perceptions from those involved therefore the test for establishing discrimination is central to any case.  The test has two stages.

First the claimant must establish that their case, on the balance of probabilities, amounts to discrimination and that the reason for their unfavourable treatment was because of their sex. The tribunal will consider what inferences it can draw from the evidence and whether discrimination took place.  This can include an evasive reply to a discrimination questionnaire or a breach of a relevant code of practice.  The respondent can rely on:

(a). Disputed events 
(b). Circumstances of an alleged comparator are different
(c). Reason for differential treatment of a comparator e.g. different conduct
(d). Discriminator behaves unreasonably/unfairly to all irrespective of sex,
race etc
(e). Special reasons for atypical conduct e.g. ill health, pressure of work

If the claimant is able to show discrimination then the burden of proof shifts to the employer who will have to show that on the balance of probabilities, that the treatment was not on the grounds of sex. Their explanation must be backed by evidence.

Whilst many cases will fail at stage one, if a claimant can show discrimination took place then stage two will be a formality.

 

How to Deal with Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment continues to make the news in the UK and the US with so many scandals emerging.  The cost to an employer for failing to deal with sexual harassment in the workplace can be unlimited.  Sexual harassment claims can be lodged in an employment tribunal and if the claimant wins the compensation can potentially be unlimited.  In this blog there are hints and tips how to deal with sexual harassment.

Sexual harassment is very serious and organisations can be held vicariously liable for the actions of their employees.  In accordance with the Equality Act 2010, it is unlawful to harass an employee because of their sex.  Harassment can include unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favours and other verbal or physical harassment of a sexual nature.  It can also include making offensive remarks about a person’s sex.  Victim and harasser can be either a man or a woman.  The victim and the harasser can be the same sex.  Harassment can create a hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive work environment.

Verbal signs of sexual harassment include:

  • comments about appearance, body or clothes
  • indecent remarks
  • questions or comments about sex life
Non verbal signs include:
  • staring at someone’s body
  • displaying sexually explicit material eg calendars, pin ups
Physical signs include:
  • physically touching
  • sexual assault
  • rape
The first step for a person being harassed would be for them to confront the harasser and ask them to stop.  If incidents continue to occur a diary should be kept.  It the behaviour continues then the person being harassed should approach their employer with a grievance – either a line manager or HR.  They do not need a specific length of service to raise a claim of sexual harassment which is a form of sex discrimination.
Following a grievance hearing, the employer should do a full investigation considering whether to suspend the perpetrator or not depending on the severity of the circumstances.  Following a full investigation a report should be produced on which the outcome should be based.  The outcome should be provided in writing to the person who has been harassed with the right to appeal if the outcome is not favourable ie no case to answer.
If it has been decided that the harassment took place then a decision must be made whether to move the perpetrator or not and whether they should be disciplined.  Serious sexual harassment is gross misconduct which may command summary dismissal.
Employers should make sure they have a robust bullying and harassment in place and training for line managers.